World Export Development Forum (WEDF) Logo








 

Discussion brief for the Export Strategy-Maker

Export Development in the Digital Economy

E-Competency and E-Commerce Capability
In Ghana

by Ghana Export Promotion Council (GEPC)
(e-mail: gepc @ ighmail.com)

  • Tawia Akyea, Executive Secretary

  • Emmanuel Addison, Director Research

  • Emmanuel Quao, Assistance Export Development Officer

in collaboration with
Dr. Osei Boeh-Ocansey
Managing Director Pioneer Food Company Ltd.
(e-mail: O-Boeh-Ocansey @ heinz.com.gh

Introduction

This paper seeks to review Ghana’s current national strategy to develop e-competency and promote e-commerce capability. To do this, the paper reports on a quantitative and qualitative study of e-competency capabilities in Ghana specifically in the export-sector, and attempts to assess impediments, real and perceived, to the development of e-commerce in Ghana. Furthermore, specific programmes underway to promote e-competency in the export sector are explored, and an attempt is made to elaborate a proposed plan for future action covering the design and implementation of a comprehensive strategy to develop e-competency within the export community. The paper also presents a detailed review of why at least two export-oriented firms have been unable to acquire e-competency or have decided not to invest in acquiring such competency.

Background

Ghana, once known as the "Gold Coast", has one of the fastest-growing economies in Africa, and is a hub of commercial activities in the West African sub-region. It is politically stable with a democratically elected government. It covers a total area of about 238 thousand square kilometres and has a population of about 18 million people. The official language in Ghana is English but is surrounded by Francophone states. It has an Atlantic coastline on the South of about 200 miles. It is estimated that 60% of all economic activity in the formal sector is located in the capital city region of Accra on the coast.

Ghana has a GDP of around US$8,000 million with a per capita income of approximately US$400. Even though the balance of payments situation shows an improved external sector performance, yet the trade balance has exhibited a persistent deficit, which is becoming a source of worry. Hence, the National policy objective is to support an aggressive export development and promotion programme designed to diversify and expand the country’s export portfolio from the narrow band of commodities in the traditional sector comprising cocoa beans, timber, gold and other minerals, into what is now referred to as non-traditional exports.

Since 1984, non-traditional exports have grown from a meagre value of less than US$2 million to US$404 million by 1999. The non-traditional export sector is broadly recognized as the sector with the greatest prospect for growth. As a matter of strategy, the Ghana Export Promotion Council (GEPC), the focal point national trade promotion agency, is devoted to the development and promotion of the non-traditional export (NTE) sector. This paper thus focuses on the activities of this sector.

1. E-competency within the Ghanaian export community – a quantitative view

  • GEPC maintains a register of exporters. This register is updated annually. Registration of exporters became mandatory only this year, 2000. Accordingly, some active exporters are not on the register. However, GEPC registered 838 exporters in 1999.
  • GEPC also compiles data on the performance of exporters. In 1999 GEPC recorded 2,597 companies as actual exporters.
  • Taking into account time constraints and logistical problems, it was decided to survey by questionnaire a select group of entities comprising 22 export companies, 15 Trade Support Institutions, 7 Trade Promotion Organisations and 6 Product and Trade Associations to represent the export community for purposes of this study. The companies were selected from the record of actual exporters. These were companies with annual export proceeds of over US$1 million.

Of the sample surveyed by questionnaire, about half did not respond. Of those who responded, more than half were connected and therefore had some e-commerce capability. Of the various groups, the Trade and Product Associations appear to be the most deprived while Trade Promotion Organisations appear to be the most up-to date in terms of e-competency.

  • Later a telephone survey of 654 companies out of 838 on the GEPC exporter registration file was carried out.

Out of the number polled, only 10 firms admitted to internet connectivity. This represents 1.5% of those polled.

  • The results of these surveys are shown in Figure 1 (table) and 2 (Doughnut) in Appendix A.

2. E-Competency within the Ghanaian export community – a qualitative assessment

Upon a careful review of the results of the surveys referred to above, it may be observed that:

  1. Of the Exporter companies polled by questionnaire, 70% of them were connected to the internet and had e-mail capabilities. However, only 11% had websites whilst none of them admitted to on-line trading.
  2. Figure 3 in Appendix A illustrates this point in a bar graph rendition.

  3. In the case of the telephone poll results, the respondents claim to use their internet connectivity for e-mail i.e. correspondence purposes mainly.
  4.  

  5. Further analysis of the questionnaire results, as regards online applications employed by Exporting companies, disclosed that
  6.  

    • For Product Promotion purposes, 33% of the firms resorted to e-mail applications, and 11% resorted to website applications.

     

      • For Information Dissemination, 44% employed e-mail facilities, and 11% used web-site facilities.

     

      • For business communications purposes, i.e. with buyers and suppliers, 70% (approx.) used e-mail facilities, but none employed web-site systems.

     

      • For finding information on competitors, 22% used e-mail [and internet facilities] but none resorted to web-site.

     

    Figure 4 in Appendix A shows these results in bar chart form.

     

    The results of the surveys, in the case of Trade Support Institutions and Trade Promotion Organisations, show a markedly more positive situation than for the exporting companies. Most trade support institutions and trade promotion organizations have not only acquired internet connections, but have established websites to provide information to web searchers. Some banks have even started servicing their clients on-line and have begun to introduce electronic payment systems to support domestic business to customer transactions.

    A broad assessment of the survey results suggest that, e-connectivity in the export sector is generally low and that hardly any e-commerce activity is being conducted.

    Upon further review and following consultations with key players in the sector, the following constraints/impediments were identified:

      1. Expensive initial connection costs,
      2. Internet as a status symbol
      3. High cost of building networks,
      4. Lack of computer skills
      5. Lack of electronic payment systems and infrastructure for authenticating payments,
      6. Lack of national policy on e-commerce, and
      7. Concerns about web security

3. Efforts by Public and Private Organizations to Overcome Non-infrastructural Impediments to Generate Awareness of E-commerce

    Past efforts to address the impediments militating against awareness of e-commerce in Ghana have been sporadic, ad hoc and largely uncoordinated. Providing a coherent report on these efforts is thereby rendered problematic.

    It is however known that several public and private institutions and firms have instituted training programmes in the use of computers, internet operations, and even website designing and management. In the public sector, the following organizations offer some training programmes:

    1. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research
    2. Institute of Social, Statistical and Economic Research, University of Ghana, Legon
    3. Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Kumasi.
    4. Ghana Institute of Management and Public Administration, Greenhill, Achimota
    5. Institute of Professional Studies, Madina.

    On the private sector side, the firms listed hereunder are easily the major awareness creators:

    1. Network Computer Systems Ltd
    2. National Cash Register Co. Ltd
    3. Internet Ghana
    4. Ghana Classifieds, and
    5. African On-Line.

    Specifically in the area of e-commerce services, the underlisted firms have introduced facilities for electronic trading on the Ghanaian scene: -

      • Network Computer Systems Ltd. has launched a subsidiary

    ghanamall.com;

      • Ghana Classifieds has also launched a subsidiary

    bestbuysghana.com; and

      • A third company, Net Afrique has launched a subsidiary

    epesewa.com

4. Review of Ghana’s Current National Strategy to Develop E-competency and Promote E-commerce Capability

    There is general awareness in government of a need to respond positively to the challenges of the digital market place. So far, even though there is no single comprehensive policy on e-competency, a series of measures have been adopted to address the issues.

    Some of these issues are as follows: -

      1. the Ministry of Communications has announced that an internet policy and regulatory framework is being developed for adoption;
      2. the telecommunication sector is in the process of full liberalisation;
      3. the Ghana Free Zones Board is offering special incentives for IT firms to establish in the zone; and
      4. the national VAT Secretariat is considering a proposal for an on-line payment of the tax.

5. Ghana Export Promotion Council (GEPC) and e-competency promotion in Ghana

    a) The GEPC is keenly aware of the possible impact of e-competency on the performance of the exporting community in terms of promotion, marketing and information management. Infact, GEPC is one of the first organisations in Ghana that switched to 100% computer dependency as far back as the early 1990s. However, there is a need now to move this competency one step higher to achieve the necessary capabilities to promote e-commerce. GEPC’s challenge therefore is to re-invent itself to acquire the necessary e-competence for export promotion and to apply this capability in promoting and supporting awareness and growth in the export community for e-commerce operations.

    b) In addition to the general constraints affecting the development of e-competency in Ghana, as mentioned earlier in this report, GEPC has been faced with a particular impediment in the form of poor resource allocation. To address this, an Export Development and Investment Fund (EDIF) is being established. The resources of the fund will enable GEPC, among other things, to implement a plan for promoting the development of e-competence in the export sector.

    c) To this end, GEPC proposes to prosecute a plan to develop e-competency and promote e-commerce capability in Ghana starting with the export community. The strategic objective of this plan is that all registered exporters should be e-competent by year 2003. To achieve this, GEPC will initiate actions under the plan for the following activities to be carried out: -

    i) institute a programme for acquisition of computer systems by export firms on soft payment terms;

     

    ii) organize training programmes at various levels for staff and personnel of exporting firms under its Export School programme;

    encourage telecommunications and other computer and internet service providers to buy into the programme;

    provide comprehensive trade information on Ghanaian exports and establish a virtual network for export product exhibition centres on the internet.

    encourage banks to set up systems to facilitate online payments for domestic and external online commerce.

    encourage the export community, including service providers, to acquire on-line connections

    encourage the export community to institute and maintain websites.

    Assist exporters to develop e-commerce based business strategies.

The plan set out above, outlines the key components of GEPC’s strategy. At the end of the plan period, it is expected that

    a) GEPC itself would be transformed into a fully fledged e-competent organisation linked on-line to the markets, trade information centres and to the export trading community in Ghana and abroad, and

    b) the export community would be fully e-competent with on-line access to GEPC and the markets with capacity to engage in fully fledged e-commerce activities.

 

APPENDIX A

The table below (figure 1) presents the number of questionnaires distributed and received:

Entities Surveyed

No. Dist

No. Received

Connectivity

% Return

%Connectivity

Export Companies

22

10

7

45

70

Trade Support institutions

15

7

5

50

71

Trade Promotion Organisations

7

4

4

57

100

Trade/Product Associations

6

2

0

33

0

Total

50

23

16

46

 

The total number of questionnaires returned fully completed represents 46% of the number distributed.

Figure 2 below shows a doughnut of online connections of firms interviewed by phone:

Figure 3 below shows internet connectivities of companies that responded to the questionnaires:

Figure 4 below summarizes the applications of online connections by companies that responded to the questionnaire type of survey:

 

Below in Figure 5 is a pie chart showing, in percentages, the impact of online business on companies that responded to the questionnaire type of survey:

APPENDIX B - CASE STUDIES

E-COMPETENCE AND E-COMMERCE
CAPABILITIES IN GHANA

A REVIEW OF A TWO EXPORT-ORIENTAL FIRMS THAT
HAVE NOT ACQUIRED E-COMPETENCY

PREPARED BY GEPC
ACCRA, GHANA

SEPTEMBER 2000

Why an export firm has:

a. been unable to acquire e-competency, or

b. has decided not to invest in acquiring such competency.

B. THE CASES

1. (a)i. ALL ROUND MARKETING COMPANY LIMITED is a registered

exporter of handicraft items from Ghana. The Chief Executive

Officer is the President of the Handicraft Exporters Association in Ghana, and the company is one of the leaders in the Handicraft export industry.

ii. The CEO is fully literate and appreciates the need to employ computers in his business. However, he is sceptical about employing e-commerce methods for his business. Even though he has an e-mail address through an Internet cafe, he is opposed to the establishment of a website to display his products and prices.

Accordingly, he cannot take orders and sell on-line.

iii. There are two reasons why this company is reluctant to acquire e-competency for its export business:

a. Competition

The CEO claims that exhibiting one’s products on the web exposes the products to the competition thereby depriving him of his competitive advantage. This phenomenon is even more pronounced where his competitors from south-east Asia are able to quote lower prices for the

same products after comparison of prices on the web. Indeed this CEO and his colleagues in the handicraft exporting community in Ghana who plan to participate in the next Berlin Import Shop Fair have advised the fair organisers not to exhibit the prices of their products as part of the advertisements on the Internet.

b. Lack of Computer Skills

The CEO is not computer literate himself. This raises problems about cost and use. Lack of familiarity produces a base line resistance to the whole idea of e-competence for trading purposes.

c. Assessment

The resistance perceived in this case could be reversed by remedial action directed at

- arranging computer skills development for the CEO; and

- working out a system for exhibition of products on the web without compromising price negotiation advantages.

2. FAMAPINE LIMITED

a. This company was recently established to buy and pack fresh pineapples for export. It has received strong support from a major donor agency. It has acquired computer equipment, has Internet connection and possesses an e-mail address. It however does not have a website and is hesitating about operating an e-commerce facility.

b. Their reasons for hesitating are that:

i. They lack in house expertise to manage on-line trading activity.

ii. They are unfamiliar with e-commerce operations.

iii. They recognise that the system for securing payment in an e-commerce environment is either non-existent or is too complicated.

iv.  Service provider contacted to host/facilitate an e-commerce operation is quoting prices that they find untenable (1% on annual turn-over)

c. Assessment:

In this case as well, remedial action could reverse the situation, by addressing the company’s

- computer skills development needs through training;
- awareness creation on e-commerce;
- review payment protocols with banking community; and
- develop rapport with service providers to develop a pro-active attitude to the needs of export companies.

The proposed GEPC plan has elements for addressing these concerns as well.

GEPC
Accra
September 2000

Top of page

Posted 11 October 2007