Bangladesh Council for Arbitration
(BCA) of the Federation of Bangladesh Chambers of Commerce and
Industry (FBCCI) (2001 Act)
The Rules may be called the "Rules of
Arbitration of the Bangladesh Council of Arbitration" framed under
the auspices of FBCCI. These Rules shall apply where any agreement,
submission or reference, in the form of an arbitration clause in a
contract or in the form of a separate agreement, provides in
writing for arbitration under these Rules of Bangladesh Council of
Arbitration (BCA) the parties shall be taken to have agreed in
writing that the arbitration shall be conducted in accordance with
these Rules or such amended Rules as the BCA may adopt from time to
time. An arbitration agreement shall be deemed to be in writing if
it is contained in-(a) a document signed by the parties; (b) an
exchange of letters, telex, telegrams, fax, E-mail or other means
of telecommunication which provide a record of the agreement; or
(c) an exchange of statement of claim and defence in which the
existence of the agreement is alleged by one party and not denied
by the other. The BCA Rules include the Appendixes and any
amendment made therein from time to time.
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
Rule 1 SHORT TITLE AND
SCOPE
1.1 These
Rules may be called the "Rules of Arbitration of the Bangladesh
Council of Arbitration" framed under the auspices of FBCCI. These
Rules shall apply where any agreement, submission or reference, in
the form of an arbitration clause in a contract or in the form of a
separate agreement, provides in writing for arbitration under these
Rules of Bangladesh Council of Arbitration (BCA) the parties shall
be taken to have agreed in writing that the arbitration shall be
conducted in accordance with these Rules or such amended Rules as
the BCA may adopt from time to time. An arbitration agreement shall
be deemed to be in writing if it is contained in-(a) a document
signed by the parties; (b) an exchange of letters, telex,
telegrams, fax, E-mail or other means of telecommunication which
provide a record of the agreement; or (c) an exchange of statement
of claim and defence in which the existence of the agreement is
alleged by one party and not denied by the other. The BCA Rules
include the Appendixes and any amendment made therein from time to
time.
Rule 2
DEFINITIONS
2.1 In
these Rules, the following words have the following meanings:
a. "Arbitration" means proceedings conducted for
resolution of dispute by a constituted Arbitral Tribunal under
these Rules;
b. "Arbitration agreement" means an agreement by
the parties to submit to arbitration all or certain disputes which
have arisen or which may arise between them in respect of a defined
legal relationship, whether contractual or not;
c. "Arbitral Award" means a decision made by the Tribunal
on the issue in dispute which includes an interim,
ex-parte, partial or final Award, as the case may
be;
d. "Arbitral Tribunal" or "Tribunal" means a Tribunal
constituted under these Rules consisting of an Arbitrator or
Arbitrators for determining a particular dispute or
difference;
e. "Claimant" includes one or more Claimants and
"Respondent" includes one or more Respondents, as the case may
be;
f. "Council" means the Bangladesh Council of
Arbitration (BCA) with its Governing Body and Tribunal.
g. "FBCCI" means Federation of Bangladesh Chamber of
Commerce and Industry.
h. "Fast Track Arbitration" means arbitration in
accordance with Rule 11;
i. "Governing Body" means the Governing Body of the
Council.
j. "International Commercial Arbitration" means an
arbitration relating to disputes arising out of legal
relationships, whether contractual or not, considered as commercial
under the law in force in Bangladesh and where at least one of the
parties is (i) an individual who is a national of, or habitually
resident in any country other than Bangladesh; or (ii) a body
corporate which is incorporated in any country other than
Bangladesh; or (iii) a company or an association or a body of
individuals whose central management and control is exercised in
any country other than Bangladesh; or (iv) the Government of a
foreign country;
k. "Legal representative" means a person who in law
represents the estate of a deceased person and includes any person
who intermeddles with the estate of the deceased, and, where a
party acts in a representative character, the person on whom the
estate devolves on the death of the party so acting;
l. "Person" means a statutory or other
organisations, company and association and includes partnership
firm;
m. "Panel" means the Panel of Arbitrators
maintained by the Council;
n. "Party" means a party to an arbitration including any
person claiming through or under him;
o. "Registrar" means the Registrar for the time being
appointed by the Governing Body and includes an Assistant Registrar
and such other person as the Governing Body may nominate for
carrying out the duties of the Registrar under these
Rules;
p. "Request" means an application requesting for
arbitration under Rule 6.1 along with all the relevant documents
under Rule 6.3.
q. "Response" means a reply to the Request in
accordance with Rule 7.1 along with a statement of defence and all
other relevant documents.
r. "Rules" means the Rules of Arbitration of the
Bangladesh Council of Arbitration (BCA) or such amended Rule(s) as
the BCA may adopt from time to time;
Rule 3 REGISTRAR'S
DUTY
3.1 The
Registrar shall act on behalf of the Council and execute all
decisions of the Governing Body and discharge all the functions
under these Rules.
3.2 The
Registrar shall receive applications for arbitration on behalf of
the Council, receive payment of fees and deposits, and appoint
Arbitrator as and when required. The Registrar shall also receive
all communications made to the Arbitral Tribunal by the parties and
communicate to them the orders and directions of the Arbitral
Tribunal, keep a register of applications to the Council and of
Awards made by the Arbitral Tribunal, keep such other books or
memoranda and make such other records or returns as the Governing
Body shall from time to time require and generally carry out the
directions of the Arbitral Tribunal so constituted under these
Rules and take such other steps as may be necessary to assist such
Arbitral Tribunal in carrying out of its functions.
3.3 The
Registrar may delegate to any officer of the Council, Chambers of
Commerce or Trade Association at the premises of which the
arbitration proceedings are taking place, to discharge such of the
functions and administrative duties of the Registrar as are deemed
proper and necessary from time to time, with reference to a
particular case or cases. However, the Registrar must supervise the
activities of such authorised officer and shall remain responsible
for all foreseeable adverse consequences.
Rule 4 RULES
APPLICABLE
4.1 Any dispute relating to any commercial matter or
any other matter arising between two or more parties in Bangladesh
or a party or parties in Bangladesh and a party or parties in a
foreign country or between foreign parties who agree or have agreed
for arbitration by the Council or under the Rules of Arbitration of
the Council, shall be determined and settled in accordance with
these Rules.
4.2 The Council shall also be competent to
administer the conduct of arbitration in any dispute or difference
relating to a commercial transaction between parties as mentioned
in Rule 4.1 where they have agreed to have their dispute arbitrated
under any other Rules of Arbitration or otherwise and have agreed
to have such arbitration administered by the Council, wholly or in
respect of some matters arising out of such arbitration.
4.3 The Council shall be competent to function as
appointing authority as contemplated under the Arbitration Rules of
the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law
(UNCITRAL).
4.4 Wherever the parties have provided or agreed for
arbitration by the Council or for arbitration under the Rules of
Arbitration of the Council, these Rules or any amendment made
thereof at the time the dispute is referred to arbitration of the
Council, shall apply.
4.5 Any Chamber of Commerce, trade association or
any arbitral or other organisation may adopt these Rules; by making
them generally available to its members or by applying them to any
dispute in which any of its members may be parties or by normally
conducting its arbitration under these Rules.
4.6 The decisions of the Council with respect to all
administrative matters relating to the arbitration shall be
conclusive and binding upon the parties and neither the Governing
Body nor the Arbitral Tribunal shall be required to give any
reasons.
Rule 5 INTERPRETATION OF
RULES
5.1 If any dispute has been raised prior to the
formation of the Arbitral Tribunal, the decision of the Governing
Body on any question relating to interpretation of these Rules or
any procedural matter thereunder shall be final and binding on the
parties. However, once the Arbitral Tribunal is formed,
notwithstanding anything contained under these Rules, any question
relating to interpretation of these Rules or any procedural matter
thereunder, so far it relates to the Tribunal so constituted, shall
be resolved by the Arbitral Tribunal and its decision on such
matter shall be final and binding on the parties.
5.2 Wherever in these Rules reference is made in
masculine it shall also include feminine. Similarly all references
in singular may also mean, where the context admits or requires,
plural and vice versa.
CHAPTER TWO
INITIATION
Rule 6 REQUEST FOR
ARBITRATION
6.1 A party wishing to have recourse to arbitration
under these Rules ("the Claimant") shall submit its written
application for Request for Arbitration ("the Request") to the
Registrar which shall contain, inter alia, following
information:
a. the
names and full addresses of the parties to the
arbitration
b.
relevant particulars concerning the -
i. number and nomination of
Arbitrator(s)
ii. an indication of any amount claimed to the
extend it is possible
iii. receipt confirming payment of the registration
fees. Without which the Request shall be treated as not having been
received by the Council.
6.2 The date on which the Request is received by the
Registrar shall, for all purposes, be deemed to be the date of the
commencement of the arbitral
proceedings.
6.3 Along with the Request the Claimant shall supply
to the Registrar the following documents in the number of copies
specified in Rule 34.1
a. statement of claim in accordance with Rule
13.1.1.
b. written documents as contemplated in Rule 1.1
containing an arbitration agreement together with the copies of all
relevant contractual documents in respect of which the dispute
arises;
c. if any Court makes an order directing that an
arbitration be held under these Rules the order of that Court or a
duly certified copy thereof shall also accompany the application
for arbitration.
6.4 In the event that the Claimant fails to comply
with either of the requirements of Rule 6.3, the Registrar may fix
a time limit within which the Claimant must comply, failing which
the file may be closed without prejudicing the right of the
Claimant to submit the same claim at a later date in another
Request.
6.5 The Registrar shall notify the Claimant its
acknowledgment of receipt of the Request within seven days from the
date of such receipt. The Registrar shall also immediately send
such notice to the Respondent along with a set of documents
submitted with the Request by the Claimant and ask for its Response
to the Request within the stipulated time in Rule 7.1. Copy of any
other or further document(s) submitted by the Claimant subsequently
must also be dispatched to the Respondent immediately.
6.6 On receipt of an application for arbitration the
Registrar may, in consultation with the Chairperson of the
Governing Body or in his absence in consultation with the member of
the Governing Body designated by him, reject the application
without giving any reason. Before deciding on the acceptability of
an application for arbitration, the Registrar may ask the parties
for further information and particulars of their claims. Similarly,
if any information or particulars regarding the arbitration
agreement furnished by Claimant with the application for
arbitration are found to be incorrect or false, at any stage
subsequently, the Arbitral Tribunal shall have a like power to
reject the application for arbitration and forfeit the deposit, if
any, made by the Claimant under these Rules.
6.7 Any party aggrieved by the decision of the
Registrar, in accepting or rejecting an application for arbitration
as above, may apply to the Court for suitable
directions.
Rule 7 THE
RESPONSE
7.1 Within 30 days from the receipt of the notice
under Rule 6.5 the Respondent shall file a written reply to the
Request in the form of a statement of defence in accordance with
Rule 13.1.2, nominate Arbitrator where applicable; and make
comments in writing, if any, as to the nomination of Arbitrator(s)
or on any other relevant issue ("the Response") along with the
receipt confirming payment of the required fees as prescribed under
these Rules.
7.2 The Respondent may apply to the Registrar for an
extension of time for filing the Response, subject to payment of
fees specified in the Schedule of Costs. The Registrar, in his
absolute discretion, may grant an extension if any reasonable
ground for such extension exists to the satisfaction of the
Registrar.
7.3 The
Respondent shall supply along with the Response all other relevant
documents to the Council in the number of copies specified in Rule
34.1.
7.4 The
Registrar shall send a copy of the Response and the documents
annexed thereto to the Claimant within seven days of the receipt of
the same.
7.5 The
Respondent may make a counterclaim against the Claimant within the
period laid down for the defence statement to the claim under Rule
7.1 provided the counterclaim arises under the same transaction as
the original claim. Any counterclaim made by the Respondent shall
be filed with its Response along with money receipt confirming the
payment of required cost under these Rules and shall
provide:
a. a description of the nature
and circumstances of the dispute giving rise to the counterclaim;
and
b. a statement of the relief
sought, including, to the extent possible, an indication of any
amount counterclaimed.
7.6 The
Claimant shall file a Reply to any counterclaim within 21 days from
the date of receipt of the counterclaim communicated by the
Council. The Registrar may grant the Claimant an extension of time
for filing the Reply, subject to payment of fees in accordance with
the Schedule of Costs, if any reasonable ground for such extension
exists to the satisfaction of the Registrar. The Registrar shall
dispatch any such Reply to the Respondent
immediately.
7.7 Failure to send a Response shall not preclude
the Respondent from denying any claim or from advancing a
counterclaim in the arbitration.
CHAPTER THREE
THE ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL
Rule 8 PANEL OF ARBITRATORS
8.1
Enlistment
8.1.1 A Panel of Arbitrators
shall be enlisted by the Governing Body of the Council from amongst
persons who are qualified and willing to serve as Arbitrators
generally or in specific fields. Council, on its own motion or on
recommendation of any member of the Governing Body of the Council
or any member of the Executive Committee of the FBCCI or its other
sister organisation, may enlist anyone as a Panel Arbitrator.
Council may set the required qualification for enlistment of a
Panel Arbitrator which may be changed from time to
time.
8.1.2 Before enlistment by the
Council, each Panel Arbitrator shall furnish to the Chairperson of
the Governing Body a written résumé of his educational
qualification and professional experience; he shall agree in
writing on fee rates stipulated by the Council under these Rules;
and he may be required to sign a declaration to the effect that he
is eligible in accordance with all the eligibility criteria which
may be specified by the Council from time to time.
8.1.3 A person of any
nationality may be enlisted in the Panel of Arbitrators.
8.2
Panel
8.2.1 The Registrar shall
prepare and maintain an up-to-date list of Panel of Arbitrators
together with adequate information as to their qualifications and
experience. Separate lists may also be kept and maintained of
Arbitrators included in the Panel for disputes in general and for
each of the fields of international trade and/or business
transactions in which the Governing Body decides that the Council
will offer arbitration facilities under these
Rules.
8.3 Choosing an
Arbitrator
8.3.1 The parties to a
dispute or the Registrar, where he appoints the Arbitrator, may
choose any person from the Panel with reference to any dispute. If
any party appoints someone residing abroad as Arbitrator, that
party will have to meet the stay and travel expenses of the person
appointed as Arbitrator. The Arbitral Tribunal may, however, make
an order in regard thereto in the Award. The Panel of Arbitrators
shall be open to inspection by anyone with the permission of the
Registrar.
8.4 Amendment of
Panel
8.4.1 The Council, at any
time, may add the name of any person to the list of Arbitrators in
the Panel or delete any name from the Panel without giving any
reason.
8.5 Special
Arbitrator
8.5.1 The Chairperson of
the Governing Body may include the name of any person, who would
qualify under these Rules in the Panel, if it is required in any
particular arbitration. The Council may decide his continuance in
the Panel even after conclusion of such particular
arbitration.
8.6
Disqualifications
8.6.1 An Arbitrator who has
attained the age of 75 years or more will automatically cease to be
a member of the Panel of Arbitrators. A person who has been
appointed as an Arbitrator in a reference before attaining the age
of 75 years may continue to serve as an Arbitrator till
pronouncement of the final Award in the said reference pending
before the Council.
8.6.2. An Arbitrator shall also
ipso facto be disqualified to serve as an Arbitrator if:
a. he
is found to be of unsound mind by a court of competent
jurisdiction; or
b. he
is adjudged as insolvent; or
c. he
is sentenced to a term of imprisonment exceeding six months for any
criminal offence involving moral turpitude; or
d. by
notice in writing to the Council he expresses unwillingness to
serve as an Arbitrator; or
e. his
name is deleted from the list of Panel by the Council under Rule
8.4.
Rule 9 CONSTITUTION OF ARBITRAL
TRIBUNAL
9.1
Expedited formation
9.1.1 In exceptional urgency, any party may apply in
writing to the Council for the expedited formation of the Arbitral
Tribunal. The application shall set out the specific grounds for
exceptional urgency in the formation of the Arbitral Tribunal
accompanying all relevant documents under Rule 6.3 as well as the
proof that all papers have duly been served upon all other parties
to the arbitration.
9.1.2 The Registrar may, in his complete discretion,
abridge or curtail any time limit or relax any requirement
specified under these Rules to expedite the formation of an
Arbitral Tribunal under Rule 9.1.1. The Registrar shall not be
entitled to abridge or curtail any time limit or relax any
requirement specified under these Rules after the formation of the
Arbitral Tribunal.
9.2
Regular formation
9.2.1 The Registrar shall
take necessary steps to constitute Arbitral Tribunal for the
adjudication of the dispute or difference as soon as practicable
once the Response is received or where no Response is received
immediately after expiry of the time limit stipulated under Rule
7.1 or 7.2, the Registrar may proceed with the formation of the
Arbitral Tribunal notwithstanding that the Request is incomplete or
the Response is missing, late or incomplete.
9. 3 Number
of Arbitrator
9.3.1 Number of
Arbitrators, prima facie, shall be the specified number in
the agreement. If the agreement specified an even number of
Arbitrators, an additional Arbitrator shall be appointed under Rule
9.4.4 when the parties nominated their respective Arbitrators and
in any other case an additional Arbitrator shall be appointed under
Rule 9.5.2.
9.3.2 Where the agreement
does not specify any number of Arbitrators and the claim does not
exceed taka five crore, the reference shall be deemed to
be to a sole Arbitrator, unless the parties to the dispute jointly
submits before the Council in writing to refer the dispute to three
Arbitrators within thirty days from the date of notification of
Request for arbitration.
9.3.3 Where the agreement
does not specified any number of Arbitrator(s) and the claim
exceeds taka five crore the dispute will be heard and
determined by three Arbitrators, unless the parties to the dispute
jointly submits before the Council in writing to refer the dispute
to a sole Arbitrator within thirty days from the date of the
notification of the Request for arbitration.
9.3.4 Where three
Arbitrators have to be appointed and any of the parties to the
dispute fails to make the necessary deposit towards the cost and
expenses of arbitration, instead of three Arbitrators, the
Registrar may appoint a sole Arbitrator unless one party agrees to
pay for all the parities.
9.3.5 Where disputed amount
is the determining factor for constituting an Arbitral Tribunal
under these Rules and the disputed amount is mentioned in a
currency other than the takas, it shall be converted into takas, at
the current official rate of exchange.
9.4 Nomination by
parties
9.4.1 If the parties have
agreed that any Arbitrator from the Panel is to be nominated by one
or more of them or by any third person authorised in the
arbitration agreement, that agreement shall be treated as an
agreement to nominate an Arbitrator for all purposes. Such
nomination may only be confirmed by the Council as Arbitrator
subject to his prior compliance with Rule 9.12.
9.4.2 Where the parties or
any third person authorised by the arbitration agreement nominate
the Arbitrator from outside the Panel. Registrar will refer the
matter to the Chairperson of the Governing Body to settle the same
in accordance with the Rule 8.5.
9.4.3 Where the parties
have agreed that a sole Arbitrator shall settle the dispute, the
Claimant in its Request for Arbitration shall provide the name of
the nominee Arbitrator and in the Response the Respondent shall
acknowledge such nomination. If in the Response no disagreement
with the Claimant's nomination is mentioned or no Response is given
on time as stipulated under Rule 7.1, acknowledgement of such
nomination shall be deemed. Upon receiving name of the sole
Arbitrator the Registrar shall confirm such nomination subject to
Rule 9.12. If the Claimant fails to mention the name of the sole
Arbitrator or the Respondent disagrees with the name provided in
the Request or no confirmation can be given due to non-conformity
of Rule 9.12, the Registrar shall proceed in accordance with the
Rule 9.5.1 for appointment.
9.4.4 Where the parties
have agreed to refer to settle the dispute to three Arbitrators,
each party shall provide one name of its nominated potential
Arbitrator in the Request and in the Response, respectively, for
confirmation by the Council. The Registrar, in consultation with
the Chairperson of the Governing Body and in his absence in
consultation with the Member of the Governing Body designated by
the Chairperson, shall appoint the third Arbitrator, who will act
as Umpire of the Arbitral Tribunal, unless the parties have clearly
demonstrated their agreement to that effect by naming the third
Arbitrator on their respective Request and Response or on a joint
application. Upon receiving the name of the Arbitrators the
Registrar shall confirm such nominations subject to Rule 9.12. If a
party fails to mention the name of its nominated potential
Arbitrator or the Respondent disagrees with the name provided in
the Request, the Registrar shall proceed in accordance with the
Rule 9.5.2 for appointment.
9.4.5 If the Arbitration
Agreement calls for nomination of Arbitrator(s) by the parties,
failure to make such nomination by a party within the stipulated
time shall be construed as an irrevocable waiver of that party's
opportunity to nominate an Arbitrator.
9.5 Appointment by
Council
9.5.1 If the arbitration
agreement or Rule 9.3.2 requires appointment of sole Arbitrator but
no procedure for nomination is agreed or no nomination or
confirmation under Rule 9.4.3 has been made, the Registrar, in
consultation with the Chairperson of the Governing Body and in his
absence in consultation with the member of the Governing Body
designated by the Chairperson, shall appoint the sole Arbitrator in
writing from among the Panel of Arbitrators. The sole Arbitrator so
nominated shall constitute the Arbitral Tribunal to hear the
dispute. The Registrar shall give notice to the parties of the
constitution of the Arbitral Tribunal.
9.5.2 If the arbitration
agreement or Rule 9.3.3 requires appointment of three Arbitrators
but no procedure for nomination is agreed or no nomination or
confirmation under Rule 9.4.4 has been made, the Registrar, in
consultation with the Chairperson of the Governing Body and in his
absence in consultation with the Member of the Governing Body
designated by the Chairperson, shall appoint all three or the
required number of Arbitrator(s) in writing from the Panel of
Arbitrators and one of the Council appointed Arbitrators shall be
designated by the Registrar as the Umpire of the Arbitral Tribunal
so constituted. The Arbitrators so appointed shall constitute the
Arbitral Tribunal. The Registrar shall give notice to the parties
of the constitution of the Arbitral Tribunal.
9.6 Multiple
parties
9.6.1 Where there are
multiple parties, whether as Claimant or as Respondent in a
dispute, and where such dispute is to be referred to three
Arbitrators, the multiple Claimants, jointly, and the multiple
Respondents, jointly, shall nominate their respective Arbitrator
for confirmation and the Registrar shall proceed in accordance with
Rule 9.4.4.
9.6.2 In the absence of
such a joint nomination and where all parties are unable to agree
to a method for the constitution of the Arbitral Tribunal,
Registrar shall appoint all three or the required number of
Arbitrator(s) from the Panel of Arbitrators in accordance the Rule
9.5.2.
9.7 Challenge of
Arbitrator
9.7.1. Any party shall have the right
to challenge the appointment of an Arbitrator within 15 days of the
receipt of the notice of his appointment or of his becoming aware
of the reason which will disqualify him as an impartial or
independent Arbitrator. Copies of the communication of challenge,
if necessary, may be sent to the concerned parties including the
other Arbitrator(s). Unless the Arbitrator in question withdraws
himself or all other parties, if notified, agree to the challenge
within 15 days of the receipt of such notice, the Registrar along
with two Members of the Governing Body designated by the
Chairperson shall consider the grounds of such challenge and their
decision shall be final and binding on all the parties.
9.8 Replacement of
Arbitrator
9.8.1 An Arbitrator shall
be replaced on his death, mental or serious physical incapacity,
upon the acceptance by the Registrar of the Arbitrator's
resignation, upon acceptance by the Council of a challenge under
Rule 9.7 or, when he is found disqualified under Rule 8.6 or, upon
the request of all the parties. An Arbitrator may also be replaced
on the Council's own initiative when it decides that he is
prevented de jure or de facto from fulfilling his
functions, or that he is not fulfilling his functions in accordance
with the Rules or within the prescribed time limits. The Registrar
shall terminate the authority of such an appointed Arbitrator and
inform him accordingly and decide upon the amount of fees and
expenses to be paid for the services rendered by him as it may
consider appropriate under the circumstances.
9.8.2 In case of the
resignation or death or termination of authority of an appointed
Arbitrator under Rule 9.8.1, a new Arbitrator will be appointed in
his place by the Registrar in case he had appointed the original
Arbitrator. Where the nomination was made by a party to the
arbitration, the Registrar shall call upon the party who had
nominated the said Arbitrator to nominate another Arbitrator in his
place. If any party refuses or neglects to nominate an Arbitrator
within 15 days of the date of notice requiring him to nominate
another Arbitrator or within such extended time, the Registrar
shall appoint another Arbitrator on behalf of that party from among
the Panel of Arbitrators and his decision will be final and binding
on all the parties.
9.8.3 The Arbitrator(s)
appointed earlier will be informed about the reconstitution of the
Arbitral Tribunal and the reconstituted Arbitral Tribunal shall
make the Award expeditiously within the time prescribed under these
Rules. The reconstituted Arbitral Tribunal in its first meeting
shall determine if and to what extent prior proceedings shall be
repeated.
9.9
Consent
9.9.1 The parties will
obtain consent of the person(s) nominated by them as Arbitrator(s)
and intimate the Council accordingly. Similarly the Registrar will
obtain the consent of the Arbitrator(s) nominated by him. After an
Arbitrator gives his consent for appointment as an Arbitrator, he
will be duly intimated about his appointment to decide the dispute
by a memo in writing under the hand of the Registrar about the
constitution of the Arbitral Tribunal.
9.10 Date of
Appointment
9.10.1 The appointment of an Arbitrator
will take effect from the date of intimation about the constitution
of the Arbitral Tribunal under Rule 9.9.
9.11 Date of
reference
9.11.1 The Registrar shall send copies
of all papers relating to arbitration received from the parties to
the dispute to the Arbitrator/Arbitrators constituting the
Arbitration Tribunal with a request to proceed with the arbitration
and the Arbitral Tribunal shall be deemed to have entered on the
reference the day on which applications, defence statement,
counterclaims, replies, documents, etc have been dispatched to the
Arbitrator/Arbitrators. Intimation shall be given to the parties of
the day on which the Bench is deemed to have entered on the
reference. If the Claimant does not file all the requisite
documents, papers, etc. or does not deposit the appropriate Fees as
per the Rules after having been given due opportunity for the
purpose by the Registrar or the Arbitral Tribunal, the Registrar or
the Arbitral Tribunal may dismiss/close the case on file.
Similarly, if the Respondent fails to produce any requisite
documents, papers including the statements of defence or
information or fails to deposit administrative fees or Arbitrators
fees etc. after having been given due opportunity for the purpose
by the Registrar or the Arbitral Tribunal, the Registrar or the
Arbitral Tribunal may proceed further with the arbitration
proceedings as per the Rules, notwithstanding such failure or
refusal by the Respondent.
9.12 General
provisions regarding Arbitrators
9.12.1 All Arbitrators conducting an
arbitration under these Rules shall be and remain at all times
impartial and independent of the parties involved in the
arbitration and he shall not act as an Arbitrator where he will
have reason to doubt as to his impartiality or independence; and
none shall act in the said arbitration as an advocate for any
party. No Arbitrator, after his appointment, shall advise any party
on the merits or likely outcome of the arbitration.
9.12.2 Before appointment or nomination
and confirmation, a prospective Arbitrator shall sign a statement
to the effect that there will be no circumstances known to him
likely to give rise to any justifiable doubts as to his
impartiality or independence, other than any circumstances already
disclosed by him before giving his consent under Rule 9.9. If any
such circumstance is disclosed, the Registrar shall provide such
information to the parties in writing and fix a time limit for any
comments from them. If the parties are willing to proceed under the
circumstances disclosed, they shall advise the Registrar
accordingly within such time fixed by the Registrar. If either
party declines to waive the presumptive disqualification or fails
to reply within the stipulated time fixed by the Registrar, the
prospective Arbitrator shall be disqualified from acting as an
Arbitrator and the vacancy so created shall be filled under Rule
9.8.
9.12.3 Each Arbitrator shall also
assume a continuing duty forthwith to disclose in writing to the
Council, to any other members of the Arbitral Tribunal and to all
the parties any circumstances likely to give rise to any
justifiable doubts as to his impartiality or independence after the
formation of Arbitral Tribunal and before the arbitration is
concluded.
9.12.4 The decisions of the Council as
to the appointment, confirmation, challenge or replacement of an
Arbitrator shall be final and the Council is not required to give
any reason for such decisions to anyone.
9.12.5 By accepting to serve, every
Arbitrator undertakes to carry out his responsibilities in
accordance with these Rules.
Rule 10 JURISDICTION
OF ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL
10.1 The
Arbitral Tribunal shall have the power to rule on its own
jurisdiction, including any objection to the initial or continuing
existence, validity or effectiveness of the Arbitration Agreement.
A decision by the Arbitral Tribunal that such other agreement is
non-existent, invalid or ineffective shall not entail ipso
jure the non-existence, invalidity or ineffectiveness of the
arbitration clause.
10.2 A plea by the Respondent that the
Arbitral Tribunal does not have jurisdiction shall be treated as
having been irrevocably waived unless it is raised not later than
the date of submission of the Response; and a similar plea in
relation to a counterclaim by the Claimant shall be treated
likewise unless it is raised by the Claimant not later than the
date of submission of the reply to the Response and counterclaim. A
plea that the Arbitral Tribunal is exceeding the scope of its
authority shall be raised promptly after the Arbitral Tribunal has
indicated its intention to decide on the matter alleged by any
party. In any case, the Arbitral Tribunal may nevertheless admit an
untimely plea if it considers the delay justified in the particular
circumstance. The Arbitral Tribunal may determine the plea to its
jurisdiction or authority in the form of a preliminary order or
later in the final Award, as it considers appropriate under the
circumstances.
CHAPTER FOUR
Bangladesh Council for
ArbitrationArbitral
Proceedings
Rule 11 FAST TRACK
ARBITRATION
11.1 The parties may opt for Fast Track Arbitration
and request the Arbitral Tribunal, before the commencement of the
arbitration proceedings or during the course of the arbitration, to
complete the proceedings in a fixed time frame of 3 to 6 months or
any other time agreed between the parties, according to the Fast
Track Arbitration procedure, as under:
a. The Arbitral Tribunal will be authorised to decide the
dispute on the written pleadings, documents and written submissions
filed by the parties without any oral hearings.
b. The Arbitral Tribunal shall have power to call for any
further information/clarification from the parties in addition to
the pleading and documents filed by them.
c. An oral hearing may be held if both the parties make a
joint Request or if the arbitration Tribunal considers an oral
hearing necessary in any particular case.
d. If an oral hearing is held, the Arbitral Tribunal may
dispense with any technical formalities and adopt such procedure as
it deems appropriate and necessary for economic and expeditious
disposal of the case.
Rule 12 PLACE OF
ARBITRATION
12.1 The place or venue of arbitration shall be
Bangladesh. The Arbitration proceedings shall be held at such place
or places in Bangladesh as the Council may determine having regard
to the convenience of the Arbitrators and the parties. In a case in
which one or both the parties are from overseas, the arbitration
proceedings may also be held at any place outside Bangladesh at the
discretion of the Council.
Rule 13 SUBMISSION OF DOCUMENTS
13.1
Statement of claim and defence statement
13.1.1 The Claimant must file its
statement of claim with the Request containing all relevant
information supported by documents, including the names, addresses
of the parties to the arbitration;a description of the nature and
circumstances of the dispute giving rise to the claim; a statement
of the relief sought, including, to the extent possible, an
indication of any amount claimed; and any comments as to the
applicable rule of law etc. of the arbitration.
13.1.2 Within the stipulated time under
Rule 7.1 the Respondent shall file its statement of defence to the
Registrar as part of the Response containing all relevant
information supported by the available documents including the
following:
a. the name and address in full;
b. confirmation or denial of all or any part of the
claims advanced by the Claimant in the Request;
c. comments as to the nature and circumstances of the
dispute giving rise to the claim;
d. Response to the relief sought; and
e. any comments concerning the number of Arbitrators and
their choice in light of the Claimant's proposals and in accordance
with the provisions of these Rules, and any nomination of an
Arbitrator required thereby.
13.2
Counterclaim and reply to counterclaim
13.2.1 The Respondent may make a
counterclaim against the Claimant provided the counterclaim arises
under the same transaction as the original claim. He must submit
the counterclaim with full details supported by the available
documents and information within the period laid down for the
submission of the Response under Rule 7.1 and the Claimant may
within twenty-one days of the notification of the counterclaim or
within the time extended by the Registrar submit a statement in
reply to the counterclaim. The Arbitral Tribunal appointed to
adjudicate upon the original claim shall also adjudicate upon the
counterclaim. The Registrar shall send a copy of the reply to the
counterclaim and all appended documents, if any, to the Respondent
for information immediately.
13.3
Amendment of claims, etc.
13.3.1 After the commencement of the
arbitration proceedings, no party shall make new claim or
counterclaim which fall outside the limits of the respective claim,
defence statement or counterclaim unless it has been authorised to
do so by the Arbitral Tribunal, which shall consider the nature of
such new claim or counterclaim, the stage of the arbitration and
other relevant circumstances. Application for amendments of the
claim, defence statement, counterclaim or reply submitted to the
Arbitral Tribunal must be formulated in writing by the party so
desiring. However, minor amendment other than adding a new claim or
counterclaim may be allowed at the sole discretion of the Tribunal.
When the additional claim or counterclaim is higher than the
original claim or counterclaim respectively the administrative fees
and Arbitrator's fee (for each Arbitrator) shall be accordingly
revised. The party making such additional claim/counterclaim shall
be responsible to deposit, if required by the Registrar, additional
fees and expenses payable under the Schedule of Costs.
13.4
Submission of other documents
13.4.1 The parties may submit with
their statements all documents, relevant samples or exhibits they
consider to be relevant and which have not previously been
submitted by any party, or may add a reference to the documents or
other evidence they will submit in future. Arbitral Tribunal may
order any party to produce to the Tribunal, and to the other
parties for inspection, or supply copies of, any documents or
classes of documents in their possession, custody or power which
the Arbitral Tribunal determines to be relevant.
13.5
Communication of documents
13.5.1 All statements, documents or
other information supplied to, or applications made to the Tribunal
by one party shall be communicated to the other party, and any
expert report or evidentiary document on which the Tribunal may
rely in making its decision shall be communicated to the parties as
soon as practicable if not immediately.
13.6 Return
of documents
13.6.1 Unless required to be filed in a
Court of law, the Council shall have full discretion to retain or
to return all books, documents or papers produced before the
Tribunal, however, the Arbitral Tribunal may direct the Registrar
at any time that the books, documents or papers produced before it
may be returned to the parties on such terms and conditions as the
Arbitral Tribunal may impose.
Rule 14 POWER OF
TRIBUNAL
14.1
Conservatory and interim measures
14.1.1 On an application of any party
the Arbitral Tribunal shall have the power to make an order of any
interim or conservatory measure it deems appropriate. The Arbitral
Tribunal may make the granting of any such measure subject to
appropriate security being furnished by the requesting party. Any
such measure shall take the form of an order, giving reasons, or of
an Award, as the Arbitral Tribunal considers appropriate. No order
under this section shall be passed without giving notice to the
other parties provided that the Arbitral Tribunal may, where it
appears that the object of taking interim measure would be defeated
by the delay, dispense with such notice.
14.2 Majority
power to continue proceedings
14.2.1 If an
Arbitrator on a three-member Arbitral Tribunal refuses or
persistently fails to participate in its deliberations, the two
other Arbitrators shall have the power, upon their written notice
of such refusal or failure to the Council, the parties and the
third Arbitrator, to proceed with the arbitration (including the
making of any decision, ruling or Award), notwithstanding the
absence of the third Arbitrator. In determining whether to continue
the arbitration, the two other Arbitrators shall take into account
the stage of the arbitration, any explanation made by the third
Arbitrator for his non-participation and such other matters as they
consider appropriate in the circumstances of the case. The reasons
for such determination shall be stated in any Award, order or other
decision made by the two Arbitrators without the participation of
the third Arbitrator.
14.2.2 In the
event that the two other Arbitrators determine at any time not to
continue the arbitration without the participation of the third
Arbitrator missing from their deliberations, the two Arbitrators
shall notify in writing the parties, through the Registrar, of such
determination; and in that event, the two Arbitrators or any party
may refer the matter to the Registrar for the revocation of that
third Arbitrator's appointment and his replacement under Rule
9.8.
14.3 Additional
powers of Arbitral Tribunal
14.3.1 The Arbitral Tribunal shall have
the power, on the application of any party or of its own motion,
but in either case only after giving the parties a reasonable
opportunity to state their views:
a. to extend or reduce any time-limit provided by the
Arbitration Agreement or these Rules for the conduct of the
arbitration or by the Arbitral Tribunal's own
orders;
b. to conduct such enquiries as may appear to the
Arbitral Tribunal to be necessary or expedient, including whether
and to what extent the Arbitral Tribunal should itself take the
initiative in identifying the issues and ascertaining the relevant
facts and the law(s) or rule of law applicable to the arbitration,
the merits of the parties' dispute and the Arbitration
Agreement;
c. to order any party to make any property, site or thing
under its control and relating to the subject matter of the
arbitration available for inspection by the Arbitral Tribunal, any
other party, its expert or any expert to the Arbitral
Tribunal;
d. to allow, only upon the application of a party, one or
more third persons to be joined in the arbitration as a party
provided any such third person and the applicant party have
consented thereto in writing, and thereafter to make a single final
Award, or separate Awards, in respect of all parties so implicated
in the arbitration;
Rule 15 LANGUAGE OF
ARBITRATION
15.1 The language of
the arbitration proceedings shall generally be in English unless
otherwise agreed by the parties. If any documents filed by a party
are in a language other than English, the party filling such
documents shall simultaneously furnish an English translation of
the documents, unless exempted by the Tribunal e.g. in a domestic
commercial arbitration documents in Bengali may also be accepted by
the Tribunal along with the documents in English. The Registrar may
make arrangements for the service of an interpreter at the request
of one or more of the parties and costs thereof shall form part of
the costs of the arbitration.
Rule 16 WAIVER
16.1 Any party who
proceeds with the arbitration with the knowledge that any provision
or requirement of these Rules has not been complied with and who
fails to state his objection thereto in writing, shall be deemed to
have waived his right to object. The parties can also mutually
agree to abandon certain provisions of these Rules provided the
Arbitral Tribunal do not think the same would frustrate the process
of arbitration.
Rule 17 PROCEDURAL
TIMETABLE
17.1 The arbitration
session will go on as far as possible on a day-to-day basis in the
convenient office hours once the hearing begins after completion of
all the formalities. The Arbitral Tribunal shall not ordinarily
adjourn a hearing at the request of any party, except where the
circumstances are beyond the control of the party and the Arbitral
Tribunal is satisfied that reasons and circumstances for the
adjournment are justified. While granting an adjournment, the
Arbitral Tribunal may make such orders regarding payment of costs
by one or both of the parties, as it deems fit and
reasonable.
Rule 18 CONDUCT OF
PROCEEDINGS
18.1
The Arbitral Tribunal shall deal with any of the dispute submitted
to it fairly and impartially and for this purpose each party shall
be given reasonable opportunity to present its case orally, or in
writing; or both, and each party shall be given reasonable
opportunity to examine all the documents and other relevant
materials file by other party or any other person concerned before
the Tribunal.
18.2 The Tribunal
shall deal with a dispute submitted to it as quick as possible by
avoiding unnecessary delay or expense. The Arbitral Tribunal shall
adopt procedures suitable to the circumstances of the arbitration;
act fairly in deciding evidence and in exercising other powers
conferred on it.
18.3 The Arbitral
Tribunal may proceed with conducting the arbitration
notwithstanding any failure by a party to comply with any of the
directions of the Arbitral Tribunal and may also proceed with the
arbitral proceedings in the absence of any or both the parties who
fail or neglect to attend at the time and place appointed by the
Arbitral Tribunal, in spite of due notice.
18.4 The Arbitral
Tribunal shall have the widest discretion to discharge its duties
allowed under these Rules and such other law or rule of law as the
Arbitral Tribunal may determine to be applicable; and at all times
the parties shall do everything necessary for the fair, efficient
and expeditious conduct of the arbitration.
Rule
19 HEARINGS
19.1 When a hearing
is to be held, the Arbitral Tribunal, giving reasonable notice, fix
the date, time and physical place of any meetings and hearings in
the arbitration, and shall summon the parties to appear before it
on the day and at the place fixed by it. If any of the parties,
although duly summoned, fails to appear without valid excuse, the
Arbitral Tribunal shall have the power to proceed with the hearing
in his absence. The Arbitral Tribunal shall be in complete charge
of the hearings, at which all the parties shall be entitled to be
present. Save with the approval of the Arbitral Tribunal, persons
not involved in the proceedings shall not be admitted. The Arbitral
Tribunal shall have the fullest authority to establish time-limits
for meetings and hearings, or for any parts
thereof.
19.2 Every party has
the right to be heard orally before the Arbitral Tribunal on the
merits of the dispute. If no such desire is expressed by any party,
the Tribunal shall decide considering all the circumstances whether
to hold oral hearings for the presentation of evidence or for oral
argument, or whether the proceedings shall be conducted on the
basis of documents and other materials only.
Rule 20
EVIDENCE
20.1 The Arbitral
Tribunal shall decide whether or not to apply any strict principles
of evidence (or any other rules) as to the admissibility, relevance
or weight of any material tendered by a party on any matter of fact
or expert opinion; and to determine the time, manner and form in
which such material should be exchanged between the parties and
presented to the Arbitral Tribunal.
20.2 The Registrar
shall make necessary arrangements for a stenographic record of
evidence whenever such record is required by a party. The cost of
the stenographic record and all transcripts thereof, if any, shall
form part of the costs of the reference.
Rule
21 WITNESSES
21.1 Before any hearing, the Arbitral Tribunal may
require any party to disclose the identity of each witness that
party wishes to call, as well as the subject matter of that
witness's testimony, its content and its relevance to the issues in
the arbitration.
21.2 The Arbitral Tribunal may also determine the
time, manner and form in which such materials should be exchanged
between the parties and presented to the Arbitral and it has a
discretion to allow, refuse, or limit the appearance of witnesses
(whether witness of fact or expert witness).
21.3 Subject to any order otherwise by the Arbitral
Tribunal, the testimony of a witness may be presented by a party in
written form, either as a signed statement or as a sworn affidavit.
However, any party may request that a witness, on whose testimony
another party seeks to rely, should attend for oral questioning at
a hearing before the Arbitral Tribunal. If the Arbitral Tribunal
orders that other party to produce the witness and the witness
fails to attend the oral hearing without good cause, the Arbitral
Tribunal may place such weight on the written testimony (or exclude
the same altogether) as it considers appropriate in the
circumstances of the case.
21.4 The Arbitral Tribunal may administer oath or
affirmation to the parties or witnesses appearing and giving
evidence. Any witness who gives oral evidence at a hearing before
the Arbitral Tribunal may be questioned by each of the parties
under the control of the Arbitral Tribunal. The Arbitral Tribunal
may put questions at any stage of his evidence.
21.5 Any individual intending to testify to the
Arbitral Tribunal on any issue of fact or expertise shall be
treated as a witness under these Rules notwithstanding that the
individual is a party to the arbitration or was or is an officer,
employee or shareholder of any party.
Rule 22 APPOINTING
LEGAL ADVISERS, EXPERTS ETC.
22.1 At a hearing, a party shall be entitled to
appear by counsel, attorney, advocate or a duly authorised adviser
or representative or personally. However, where the dispute is
purely of a commercial nature, the parties shall have no right to
be represented by lawyers except where, having regard to the nature
or complexity of the dispute, the Arbitral Tribunal considers it
necessary in the interest of justice that the parties should be
allowed to be represented by counsel, attorney or
advocate.
22.2 The Arbitral Tribunal may at its discretion at
any time or times before making the final Award and at the expense
of the parties concerned, consult any person having special
knowledge relating to the particular industry, commodity, product
or branch of trade concerned in the reference or any expert or
qualified accountant and may also at the like expenses of the
parties, consult solicitors, counsel or advocates upon any
technical question of law, evidence, practice or procedure arising
in the course of the arbitration. If the parties agree, the
Arbitral Tribunal may, at the expense of the parties, appoint any
expert, accountant, or lawyers to sit with as an assessor and take
into account the advice of such assessor. The parties shall be
given reasonable opportunity to comment on the report, information,
opinion or advice submitted in the Tribunal by the expert, legal
adviser or the assessor.
22.3 If a party to the Arbitral Tribunal so requests, the
expert or the assessor, as the case may be, shall, after delivery
of his written or oral report, participate in an oral hearing where
the parties have the opportunity to put questions to him and to
present expert witness in order to testify on the points at issue.
The expert, or the assessor, as the case may be, shall, on the
request of a party, make available to that party all documents,
goods or other property in the possession of him with which he was
provided in order to prepare his report.
Rule 23 CONSOLIDATING
PROCEEDINGS AND CONCURRENT
HEARING
23.1 The parties
shall be free to agree to the effect that any arbitration
proceedings shall be consolidated with other arbitral proceedings
or concurrent hearings of arbitration between the same parties
shall be held on such terms as may be agreed. The Arbitral Tribunal
shall have no power to consolidate the proceedings or concurrent
hearing unless the same is given by the parties on agreed terms to
the Tribunal.
23.2 Where there are
two or more applications for arbitration by the Council and the
issue involved in the dispute arises out of same transactions, the
Registrar may, if he thinks proper to do so and with the consent of
the parties, fix the hearing of the disputes to be heard jointly or
refer the applications to the same Tribunal. The Awards, however,
shall be given separately in each case.
Rule 24 CLOSE OF
PROCEEDINGS
24.1 When it is
satisfied that the parties have had a reasonable opportunity to
present their cases, the Arbitral Tribunal shall declare the
proceedings closed. Thereafter, no further submission or argument
may be made, or evidence produced, unless requested or authorised
by the Arbitral Tribunal.
Rule 25 TERMINATION OF
PROCEEDINGS
25.1 The arbitral proceedings shall be terminated by the
final Arbitral Award or by an order of the Arbitral Tribunal
where-
a.the Claimant
withdraws his claim and no objection of the Respondent in this
regard shall be taken into account unless he has a
counterclaim;
b. the parties agree on the termination of the
proceedings; or
c. the Arbitral Tribunal finds that the continuation of
the proceedings has for any other reason become unnecessary or
impossible.